Tag: History of Classical Music

Overview

A forgotten virtuoso of the romantic piano

Henri Herz was a 19th-century Franco-Austrian pianist, composer and piano maker. Although he enjoyed immense popularity during his lifetime, particularly as a virtuoso, his music has now largely been forgotten.

1. Brief biography

Birth: 6 January 1803, Vienna (Austria)
Training: He studied at the Paris Conservatoire, where he was a pupil of Antoine Reicha.

Pianist career:
He caused a sensation in Parisian salons and European concert halls.
He is often compared to Chopin, Liszt and Thalberg, although he was less innovative.

Piano entrepreneur and manufacturer:
He founded a piano factory that enjoyed some success.
He took part in the 1855 World’s Fair with his instruments.

Professor at the Paris Conservatory (1842-1874).

Died: 5 January 1888, Paris.

2. His musical style

Henri Herz is a representative of pianistic brilliance, a school of music emphasising virtuosity and elegance rather than emotional depth.

🔹 Characteristics of his music:

Charming and light melodies.
Passages of spectacular virtuosity (fast strokes, octaves, arpeggios).
Simple, often conventional harmony.
Style close to Hummel, Kalkbrenner, Moscheles, but less innovative than Chopin or Liszt.
Music often designed to please a fashionable audience, rather than to revolutionise piano writing.

3. Main works

🎹 Piano music

Eight Concertos for piano and orchestra (Nos. 1 to 8)
Numerous fantasies and brilliant variations on famous opera arias (Don Giovanni, The Magic Flute, etc.).
Grand galop chromatique, op. 88 – a virtuoso piece typical of the 19th century.
Caprices and Études de virtuosité, very popular at the time.

📜 Other works

A few vocal melodies and duets.
Some chamber music pieces, but his talent was mainly focused on solo piano.

4. Reception and posterity

🔹 His success in the 19th century:

Highly appreciated in salons and among piano lovers.
He toured Europe and America, where he was a star attraction.

🔹 Why is he forgotten today?

His style is considered superficial and uninnovative, unlike Chopin or Liszt.
Most of his works are salon music, which has lost prestige.
His music is often considered a historical curiosity rather than an essential repertoire.

Conclusion

Henri Herz was a star of the Romantic piano, but his legacy rests more on his role as virtuoso and piano manufacturer than on his musical contribution. His music, although charming and brilliant, is eclipsed by the great piano masters of his time. However, his concertos and études are still played by some pianists curious to rediscover this forgotten part of Romanticism.

History

Henri Herz is a fascinating 19th-century character, a pianist whose worldwide fame eventually faded behind figures such as Chopin and Liszt. Yet he was one of the most famous musicians of his time, adored by the public for his brilliant playing and talent for improvisation, while being criticised by his peers for his lack of musical depth.

Born in Vienna in 1803 into a family of Jewish origin, Herz grew up in the heart of the European music capital. From a very young age, he showed exceptional talent for the piano. But it was in Paris that he really made his mark. He entered the Conservatoire at the age of twelve, studying under Antoine Reicha, who gave him a solid grounding in theory.

From the 1820s onwards, Herz’s career took off. He performed in Parisian salons, the essential venues of fashionable musical life, where he shone with his elegance and virtuosity. His pianistic style, characterised by a fluid and scintillating execution, was enormously popular with the public. He composed works tailored to these prestigious circles: fantasies, variations on opera arias and salon pieces designed to amaze the audience. His pieces, often light and embellished with rapid strokes and airy arpeggios, are in the tradition of the brilliant piano inherited from Hummel and Kalkbrenner.

But Henri Herz was not only a pianist; he was also a shrewd businessman. Seeing the growing success of the piano as a domestic instrument, he went into piano manufacturing. He founded his own factory, which became flourishing, and developed instruments renowned for their precise touch and clear sound. His participation in the 1855 Universal Exhibition, where he presented his pianos, sealed his success in the industrial field.

In parallel to his commercial activities, he pursued an impressive career as a concert pianist. At a time when international tours were still rare, he travelled throughout Europe, then crossed the Atlantic for a tour of the United States. There, he was welcomed like a true star, playing to packed houses and helping to popularise the piano in America.

In 1842, Herz was appointed professor at the Paris Conservatoire. He taught there for more than thirty years, training several generations of pianists. Yet, despite his fame and fortune, he suffered a certain contempt from his most avant-garde contemporaries. Chopin, for example, considered him a superficial pianist, and Liszt, who cultivated a more transcendental approach to music, saw him as a musician too rooted in social entertainment.

In his final years, Herz gradually withdrew from the limelight. His music, once so highly regarded, began to fall out of fashion with the rise of the more introspective Romanticism of Brahms and Schumann. He died in 1888, almost forgotten by the new generations.

Today, Henri Herz remains a paradoxical figure: a huge star in his time, he is now consigned to history as a composer of brilliant music, but without the emotional depth that might have ensured his lasting posterity. His concertos and piano pieces are still occasionally rediscovered, bearing witness to a fascinating period of romantic piano music, that of a time when pure virtuosity and charm took precedence over introspection.

Chronology

1803 – Birth in Vienna

Henri Herz was born on 6 January 1803 in Vienna, then the capital of the Austrian Empire. He came from a Jewish family, but spent most of his life in France.

1816 – Arrival in Paris and enrolment at the Conservatoire

At the age of 13, Herz left for Paris to continue his musical training. He entered the Paris Conservatoire, where he studied piano under Louis-Barthélémy Pradher and composition with Antoine Reicha.

1820s – Career beginnings and success in the salons

In the 1820s, he began to perform in Parisian salons and to compose brilliant pieces for the piano, notably fantasies and variations on opera arias. He quickly established himself as a fashionable virtuoso, alongside contemporaries such as Kalkbrenner and Thalberg.

1828 – First Piano Concerto, op. 34

He composed and performed his First Piano Concerto, which was a great success. It was the first in a series of eight concertos, all characterised by a virtuoso and elegant style.

1830s – Acclaim and rivalry with Liszt and Chopin

In the 1830s, he became a key figure on the Parisian music scene.
He entered into rivalry with Franz Liszt, whose more flamboyant and innovative style gradually stole the limelight from him.
Chopin and other critics considered his music to be too superficial and commercial.

1839-1842 – Triumphant tour of America

In 1839, Herz began a long tour of the United States, Central America and South America, where he played to enthusiastic crowds.
He was one of the first European pianists to undertake such a large-scale American tour.
In 1844, he published a book of memories of this adventure: Mes voyages en Amérique (My travels in America).

1842 – Professor at the Paris Conservatoire

On his return to France, he was appointed professor of piano at the Paris Conservatoire, a post he held until 1874.

1850s – Piano manufacturing and the Universal Exhibition

He founded his own piano factory, which enjoyed great success.
In 1855, he took part in the Universal Exhibition in Paris, where his pianos were presented as quality instruments.
He made his fortune thanks to this activity, becoming as well-known as a piano maker as he was as a musician.

1860s – Decline of his popularity

His brilliant but conventionally judged pianistic style began to go out of fashion in the face of the more profound works of Schumann, Liszt and Brahms.
He continued to teach and compose, but his influence on the music scene gradually diminished.

1874 – Retirement from the Conservatoire

After more than 30 years of teaching, he retired and withdrew from public life, although he continued to take an interest in instrument making.

1888 – Death in Paris

Henri Herz died in Paris on 5 January 1888, at the age of 84. He fell into oblivion after his death, and his name is little known today, although some of his works are being rediscovered by curious pianists.

Conclusion

Henri Herz was a leading figure of the brilliant romantic piano, a virtuoso adored by audiences but criticised by purists. His story illustrates the fleeting glory of fashionable 19th-century artists, eclipsed by the musical revolutions of their contemporaries.

Music characteristics

Henri Herz’s music is a perfect reflection of the brilliant Romantic piano of the 19th century, a style designed to dazzle listeners with virtuosity and lightness rather than to express emotional depth or harmonic innovation. Although his work lost prominence after his death, it bears witness to an era when the piano was the instrument of choice for salons and social concerts.

1. A brilliant and virtuoso style

🔹 Herz belongs to the school of the brilliant piano, a style inherited from Hummel and Kalkbrenner, and also found in Thalberg and Czerny. His works are designed to showcase the pianist’s dexterity with:

Fast and fluid strokes (sixteenth-note scales, virtuoso arpeggios).
Powerful octaves and chords, particularly in his concertos.
A clarity and lightness of execution, ideal for captivating the audience.

💡 Example: The Grand galop chromatique, op. 88 is a typical piece of this brilliant art, with its swift and scintillating passages.

2. A charming but conventional melodic style

🎵 Herz’s music favours elegant and lilting melodies, often inspired by the operas of his time (Rossini, Bellini, Donizetti). He composed numerous variations and paraphrases on famous tunes, like Liszt, but with a lighter and more ornamental tone.

🔹 However, his harmony remains classical and predictable, far from the harmonic daring of Chopin or Liszt. His chord progressions follow familiar patterns, designed to flatter the ear rather than surprise.

💡 Example: His fantasies on opera themes perfectly illustrate this style, with brilliant ornaments and accessible lyricism.

3. Music designed to please the audience

🎭 Unlike Chopin, who saw the piano as an instrument of intimate expression, Herz composed primarily for a social audience and piano enthusiasts. His music was often intended for salons, where it served to entertain and impress rather than move.

🔹 This desire to please explains:

Great harmonic and formal simplicity, making his music accessible.
A profusion of salon pieces, such as waltzes, mazurkas and polkas.
A tendency to favour effect over substance, which earned him criticism from his more avant-garde contemporaries.
💡 Example: Les Rêveries musicales, op. 45 illustrates this pleasant and seductive music, without much complexity.

4. Orchestration is often secondary

🎻 In his eight piano concertos, Herz emphasises the piano, often relegating the orchestra to an accompanying role. Unlike Chopin or Liszt, who seek a subtle interaction between soloist and orchestra, Herz often uses the orchestra as a simple background sound.

💡 Example: His Piano Concerto No. 1, Op. 34, although virtuoso, follows a relatively conventional orchestration.

5. An influence on piano pedagogy

🎹 Herz was not only a composer, but also an educator. His clear style and concern for immediate effect made him a composer appreciated by beginner and intermediate pianists. His studies and exercises have long been used in piano teaching, in the same way as Czerny.

💡 Example: His Progressive Piano Lessons are designed to develop technique without much musical complexity.

Conclusion: a forgotten brilliant composer

Henri Herz embodies a nineteenth-century aesthetic that has lost its appeal with the evolution of musical language. While his brilliant and seductive works were all the rage in the salons of his time, they were eclipsed by the innovations of Chopin, Liszt and Schumann, who were able to give the piano a more marked emotional and harmonic depth. Today, he remains a historical curiosity, appreciated for his testimony to a golden age of piano virtuosity.

Relations

Henri Herz (1803-1888) was an Austrian pianist, composer and piano maker who became a naturalised French citizen. He moved in 19th-century Parisian musical circles and had various relationships with other musicians, performers, institutions and non-musical figures. Here is an overview of his notable connections:

1. Composers and musicians

Frédéric Chopin: Chopin and Herz were contemporaries, but their musical styles and philosophies differed. Chopin despised Herz’s music, which he found too commercial and brilliant, unlike his own more expressive and introspective style.

Franz Liszt: Liszt was a harsh critic of Herz, considering him a salon musician without artistic depth. They were competitors in the field of piano virtuosity. Liszt mocked Herz in his writings on music.

Sigismond Thalberg: Thalberg, another piano virtuoso, was closer to Herz’s style than Liszt, and they shared a taste for salon music and brilliant pianistic effects.

Hector Berlioz: Berlioz openly mocked Herz’s music, which he found superficial. In his writings, he sometimes referred to it with irony.

Jacques Offenbach: Offenbach worked as a cellist in the orchestra of the Théâtre des Bouffes-Parisiens, where he was able to meet Herz.

2. Performers and institutions

François-Joseph Fétis: The Belgian critic and musicologist Fétis wrote about Herz’s music, often in mixed terms.

The Paris Conservatoire: Herz was a piano teacher there from 1842 and trained several students.

Orchestras: Although Herz was primarily a composer and soloist of piano music, he collaborated with orchestras for his concertos.

3. Non-musical personalities

Piano maker: Herz was also a piano entrepreneur and manufacturer. He had connections with the piano industry and trade in Paris.

World’s fairs: He presented his pianos at the 1855 World’s Fair and won a medal.

Patrons and Parisian salons: Herz frequented the salons of the Parisian bourgeoisie, where he played and promoted his music.

Henri Herz was therefore a key figure in 19th-century Parisian music, although he was often criticised by his more innovative contemporaries.

Similar composers

Henri Herz (1803-1888) was a virtuoso pianist and prolific composer specialising in salon music, characterised by a brilliant, light style often intended to appeal to the general public. He was also a piano maker, which influenced his composing style, emphasising the technical and sound qualities of the instrument.

Other composers of his time shared similar characteristics in terms of style, career and influence in the world of the piano:

1. Salon music composer-pianists and virtuosos
These composers were known for their brilliant and accessible pieces, often written to appeal to a Parisian audience:

Ignaz Moscheles (1794-1870): An Austro-British pianist, Moscheles combined virtuosity with classical elegance. His style is similar to Herz’s, although somewhat more inspired by Beethoven.
Friedrich Kalkbrenner (1785-1849): A major figure on the French piano scene before the arrival of Chopin and Liszt. He had a brilliant style and influenced Herz in terms of piano playing and business (Kalkbrenner was also a piano entrepreneur).
Sigismond Thalberg (1812-1871): A specialist in ‘third-hand’ playing (melody in the centre surrounded by accompaniments), he was a direct competitor of Liszt and Herz in piano virtuosity.
Theodor Döhler (1814-1856): A pupil of Czerny, he composed salon pieces that were very fashionable at the time, often full of brilliant pianistic effects.
Carl Czerny (1791-1857): Although he is best known today for his studies, Czerny wrote many brilliant works intended for a wide audience, like Herz.

2. Composers at the crossroads of virtuosity and popular music

These composers combined pianistic virtuosity with elements borrowed from popular styles or opera:

Louis Moreau Gottschalk (1829-1869): American pianist influenced by Afro-Caribbean rhythms and popular music. He shares with Herz a spectacular and accessible side, albeit with a more exotic style.
Charles-Valentin Alkan (1813-1888): A contemporary of Herz, Alkan was a virtuoso pianist, but his style was much more original and daring. Nevertheless, he composed brilliant pieces that could appeal to the same audience.
Emile Prudent (1817-1863): French pianist whose music oscillated between virtuosity and lyrical melody, similar to that of Herz.
Anton Rubinstein (1829-1894): Founder of the St Petersburg Conservatory, he was both a piano virtuoso and a prolific composer of accessible pieces.

3. Composers linked to the piano industry

Like Herz, some musicians were involved in the manufacture and promotion of the piano:

Johann Baptist Cramer (1771-1858): German-born pianist and composer based in England, who founded a piano company and wrote brilliant educational works.
Camille Pleyel (1788-1855): Piano maker and composer, although his role in the industry overshadowed his music.

Conclusion

Henri Herz belonged to a musical movement where virtuosity and accessibility took precedence over harmonic or formal innovation. His works were intended for salons and wealthy amateurs, a domain shared with composers such as Kalkbrenner, Thalberg and Moscheles. However, unlike Liszt or Chopin, his work has left less of a mark on the history of the piano, remaining rooted in a charming but not very innovative style.

As a pianist

Henri Herz (1803-1888) was not only a composer and piano maker, but also a virtuoso pianist who enjoyed great success in his time. His playing and his career as a concert pianist are representative of the pianistic school of the early 19th century, centred on virtuosity, elegance and seduction of the audience.

1. A pianist in Parisian fashion

Herz followed in the tradition of the virtuoso pianists of his time, such as Kalkbrenner, Thalberg and Moscheles. His playing was characterised by technical brilliance, fluid execution and an approach often considered seductive but lacking in depth in terms of expression. Unlike figures such as Chopin or Liszt, he favoured a lighter style, often described as ‘salon music’.

With Paris being the musical centre of the piano in the 19th century, Herz found a loyal audience there and a strong demand for his brilliant and accessible works. His concerts attracted the bourgeois elite, who appreciated his elegant playing and sense of showmanship.

2. Virtuosity and mixed reviews

While the public acclaimed him, music critics were more divided. Supporters of the deeper Romanticism (such as Chopin, Berlioz and Liszt) considered him a purely commercial musician, producing effective music but without much artistic value.

Franz Liszt mocked Herz, considering him a parlor pianist devoid of expressive genius.
Hector Berlioz wrote about him ironically, emphasising his commercial success but criticising his lack of musical depth.
Chopin, although less virulent, did not consider Herz to be an important musician.

3. A globe-trotting pianist

In addition to his Parisian career, Herz was one of the first pianists to undertake major international tours, thus anticipating Liszt’s virtuoso tours. His most significant journeys included:

Tour of America (1845-1851): Herz travelled to the United States, where he gave numerous successful concerts and observed the growth of the piano market. He described his experiences in a book, ‘Mes voyages en Amérique’ (1866), in which he recounts his journey and his view of American society.
Tours in Europe and Brazil: He also performed in England, Germany and South America.

4. A pianist-entrepreneur

Herz was not content to be a performer: he was also a businessman. He founded a piano factory that enjoyed great success in the 19th century. His concerts were also a way of promoting his own instruments.

5. Decline and posterity

With the emergence of a new, deeper and more expressive school of pianism (Liszt, Chopin, Alkan), Herz’s style lost popularity. However, he continued to teach at the Paris Conservatoire, influencing many students.

Today, Henri Herz is rarely played in concert, and his influence as a pianist has faded in the face of more prominent figures of his time. However, he remains an important figure in understanding the evolution of virtuoso piano and 19th-century musical culture.

Famous works for solo piano

Henri Herz composed a large quantity of piano music, mainly brilliant pieces intended for salons and amateurs. His style is characterised by elegant virtuosity and fluid pianistic writing, often in the spirit of variations and paraphrases. Here are some of his best-known works for solo piano:

1. Brilliant Variations and Fantasies

Variations on a Theme by Rossini, Op. 2 – An early work demonstrating his skill in the art of variations.
Variations on a Theme from Don Giovanni (Mozart), Op. 57 – A tribute to Mozart’s famous opera, with virtuoso passages.
Fantasy and brilliant variations on Meyerbeer’s ‘Robert le Diable’, op. 92 – Illustrating the influence of the opera on his compositions.
Great variations of bravura on ‘God Save the King’, op. 120 – An example of virtuosity on a popular tune.

2. Studies and educational pieces

Études caractéristiques, op. 51 – Designed to combine virtuosity and musicality.
Le Bouquet des enfants, op. 133 – A collection of more accessible pieces, intended for young pianists.

3. Brilliant and danceable pieces

Les Arpèges harmoniques, op. 86 – A technical piece exploiting arpeggios in a virtuoso manner.
Les Grâces, valse brillante, op. 166 – An elegant waltz, typical of the salon style.
Le Tourbillon, galop brillant, op. 179 – A lively and lively gallop, illustrating the festive spirit of the 19th century.

4. Great concert works

The Nightingale, op. 159 – A piece inspired by the song of the bird, with delicate and virtuoso effects.
Grande caprice de concert, op. 118 – A piece designed to demonstrate pianistic mastery.

Although these works are not as often performed today as those of Chopin or Liszt, they bear witness to the success that Herz enjoyed in his time, particularly with audiences at Parisian salons and lovers of brilliant and accessible music.

Famous works

Henri Herz is mainly known for his works for solo piano, but he also composed for other ensembles. His most notable works outside of solo piano are as follows:

1. Concertos for piano and orchestra

Herz wrote eight piano concertos, which follow a brilliant and virtuoso style, intended to showcase the soloist:

Piano Concerto No. 1 in A major, Op. 34
Piano Concerto No. 2 in C minor, Op. 74
Piano Concerto No. 3 in D minor, Op. 87
Piano Concerto No. 4 in E minor, Op. 131
Piano Concerto No. 5 in F minor, Op. 180 – one of his best known.
Piano Concerto No. 6 in A major, Op. 192
Piano Concerto No. 7 in B flat major, Op. 207
Piano Concerto No. 8 in A flat major, Op. 218

2. Chamber music

Herz wrote little chamber music, but there are a few works in which the piano plays a central role:

Grand Trio for Piano, Violin and Cello, Op. 58
Duo for piano and violin, op. 100

3. Works for voice and piano

Herz also composed melodies and romances, popular in the salons of his time:

Chant du gondolier, op. 83 – An elegant romance.
Le Retour, op. 126 – A melody imbued with lyricism.

4. Orchestral music

Although Herz was primarily a composer for piano, he also worked on a number of orchestral pieces related to his concertos, although these works are rarely performed today.

His concertos remain his most important works apart from solo piano, showcasing his brilliant virtuoso style.

(This article was generated by ChatGPT. And it’s just a reference document for discovering music you don’t know yet.)

Classic Music Content Page

Best Classical Recordings
on YouTube

Best Classical Recordings
on Spotify