Overview
The Transcendental Études, S.139 by Franz Liszt are a set of twelve virtuosic piano études that stand as one of the most demanding and visionary works in the piano repertoire. Completed and published in 1852, these études represent the pinnacle of Romantic pianism and Liszt’s philosophy of pushing the piano beyond conventional limits—technically, musically, and emotionally.
🔹 Overview
✦ Title:
Transcendental Études (Études d’exécution transcendante), S.139
✦ Composer:
Franz Liszt (1811–1886)
✦ Year of Final Publication:
1852 (final revision of earlier versions from 1826 and 1837)
✦ Dedication:
Carl Czerny – Liszt’s former teacher
🔹 Historical Background
Liszt composed the earliest version of these études in 1826 at age 15 (published as Étude en douze exercices, S.136). He revised them into a much more difficult version in 1837 (Douze Grandes Études, S.137), and finally refined and “musicalized” them into the 1852 version (S.139) that balances virtuosity with expression.
🔹 Musical and Technical Character
These études are more than technical drills—they are mini tone poems, each with a unique poetic or narrative character. They explore transcendence not just through finger dexterity but through deep musical expression, structural innovation, and emotional range.
Each étude is highly individual and carries a descriptive title (except No. 2 and No. 10, which Liszt left untitled but which have acquired nicknames).
🔹 The Twelve Études (S.139)
No. Title Key Character Summary
1 Preludio C major A brief and energetic prelude introducing the cycle
2 (Untitled) A minor Fiery and stormy with double-note technique
3 Paysage F major Pastoral, serene evocation of countryside landscapes
4 Mazeppa D minor Programmatic, wild gallop; based on Victor Hugo’s poem
5 Feux Follets B♭ major Flickering, ghostly; known for extreme difficulty and delicacy
6 Vision G minor Grand and solemn; evokes cataclysmic, majestic imagery
7 Eroica E♭ major Heroic and declamatory with martial rhythms
8 Wilde Jagd C minor “Wild Hunt”; turbulent and relentless, full of octave leaps
9 Ricordanza A♭ major Nostalgic, lyrical, and ornamented like a bel canto aria
10 (Untitled) (“Appassionata”) F minor Passionate and intense, often compared to Chopin’s style
11 Harmonies du soir D♭ major Richly harmonized, impressionistic textures; groundbreaking
12 Chasse-neige B♭ minor Evokes a snowstorm; swirling and haunting atmosphere
🔹 Technical Innovations
Demands extreme virtuosity, endurance, and color control
Explores double-note passages, hand-crossings, wide leaps, octave runs, and pedal finesse
Often uses advanced textures and sonorities not common before Liszt
🔹 Legacy and Influence
Set a new standard for the concert étude as an art form
Inspired later composers like Rachmaninoff, Scriabin, and Debussy
Anticipates 20th-century pianism, especially in Feux Follets and Harmonies du soir
🔹 Performance Considerations
Generally considered among the most difficult pieces ever written for piano
Requires not only technical prowess but also poetic insight, structural control, and emotional range
Often played individually or in subsets due to difficulty and length
Characteristics of Music
The Transcendental Études, S.139 by Franz Liszt form not just a set of studies but a monumental suite of self-contained yet thematically and emotionally connected piano compositions. Their musical characteristics reflect Liszt’s philosophy of transcendence—not only as a technical challenge but as a spiritual, poetic, and expressive ideal.
🎼 MUSICAL CHARACTERISTICS OF THE COLLECTION
🔹 1. Virtuosity as Expression
Liszt transcends the idea of études as technical drills. These pieces transform technique into expressive devices:
Scales, arpeggios, octaves, trills, and leaps serve narrative or atmospheric purposes
Each étude is a character piece, often with a programmatic or poetic element
🔹 2. Contrasts of Character and Mood
The études cover a wide emotional spectrum:
From explosive (No. 4 “Mazeppa”, No. 8 “Wilde Jagd”)
To intimate (No. 3 “Paysage”, No. 9 “Ricordanza”)
To mystical or impressionistic (No. 11 “Harmonies du soir”, No. 12 “Chasse-neige”)
Liszt weaves a narrative arc through contrasting moods, suggesting a spiritual or epic journey.
🔹 3. Programmatic and Poetic Elements
Most études are titled and allude to extramusical imagery:
“Feux Follets” (Will-o’-the-Wisps): light, elusive
“Mazeppa”: based on Victor Hugo’s poem about a man tied to a wild horse
“Ricordanza”: nostalgia and reverie
“Chasse-neige”: swirling snow, desolation
These études could be seen as tone poems for solo piano—a concept Liszt would later champion in orchestral music.
🔹 4. Innovative Harmony and Texture
Liszt’s harmonic language is adventurous and chromatic:
Uses enharmonic shifts, altered chords, and ambiguous tonality (especially in Nos. 5, 11, and 12)
Explores coloristic textures: pedaling effects, impressionistic sonorities
“Harmonies du soir” anticipates Debussy and Scriabin
🔹 5. Formal Variety
The études employ a variety of forms and structures:
Ternary (ABA) forms in lyrical pieces like “Ricordanza”
Sonata-like or developmental forms in “Mazeppa” and “Eroica”
Rhapsodic or improvisatory shapes in “Feux Follets” or “Vision”
Despite being études, the pieces are architecturally sophisticated, integrating virtuosic display with structural depth.
🔹 6. Technical Innovation
Liszt introduces groundbreaking technical devices:
Double-note runs (No. 2)
Wide leaps and hand crossings (No. 4)
Ghostly finger independence (No. 5)
Massive chordal textures and orchestral voicing (Nos. 6, 7, 11)
Each étude is a laboratory of pianistic invention.
🔹 7. Thematic and Tonal Cohesion
Though not a cyclic work in the strict sense, the études are unified by key relationships and motivic echoes:
Key progression loosely follows a modulatory arc, creating contrast and balance
Certain gestures (e.g., fanfare motives, swirling figures) recur in different guises
Some scholars argue for a quasi-symphonic structure or a poetic journey from light (No. 1 “Preludio”) to desolation and transcendence (No. 12 “Chasse-neige”).
🧭 Summary
The Transcendental Études, S.139 are:
A synthesis of poetry and pianism
A cycle of expressive, technically radical miniatures
A cornerstone of Romantic piano music that combines sheer difficulty with visionary artistry
They foreshadow the evolution of impressionism, symbolism, and the modernist piano tradition, while still grounded in Liszt’s unique Romantic voice.
Analysis, Tutoriel, Interpretation & Importants Points to Play
A comprehensive guide to Franz Liszt’s Transcendental Études, S.139, including analysis, tutorial, interpretation, and key performance tips for each étude. This overview focuses on their technical challenges, musical essence, and interpretive demands.
🎼 Franz Liszt – Transcendental Études, S.139 (1852)
✅ General Performance Strategy (for the Whole Set)
Prepare mentally and physically: These études require not just finger skill, but stamina, memory, and emotional control.
Study each étude separately as a self-contained musical universe.
Practice hands separately, slowly, then integrate.
Use the score analytically: mark harmonic pivots, thematic returns, and fingerings.
Pedaling must be controlled and varied—Liszt often writes for orchestral-like sonority.
Tone control is essential—dynamics should be expressive, not just loud.
🎵 Étude No. 1 – Preludio (C major)
✦ Analysis:
A short preface (about 1 minute).
Brilliant fanfare gestures, repeated chords, and rapid scalar passages.
✦ Tutorial Tips:
Practice rhythmic clarity in repeated chords.
Use forearm rotation to avoid tension.
✦ Interpretation:
Bold, radiant, and declamatory.
Treat as a “curtain-raiser” to the cycle.
🎵 Étude No. 2 – (Untitled) (A minor)
✦ Analysis:
Fast, stormy, and aggressive.
Features double-note runs, syncopations, and leaping left hand.
✦ Tutorial Tips:
Double notes: practice legato trills in thirds and sixths.
Control balance between hands.
✦ Interpretation:
Keep it ferocious but not noisy.
Maintain rhythmic drive.
🎵 Étude No. 3 – Paysage (F major)
✦ Analysis:
Pastoral and lyrical.
Evokes nature with long melodic lines and gentle undulations.
✦ Tutorial Tips:
Keep left hand legato and flowing.
Right-hand melody needs subtle shaping.
✦ Interpretation:
Tranquil and introspective, like gazing at a calm landscape.
🎵 Étude No. 4 – Mazeppa (D minor)
✦ Analysis:
Based on Victor Hugo’s poem: wild gallop, rise to greatness.
A full-fledged tone poem with octaves, leaps, and thematic transformation.
✦ Tutorial Tips:
Practice octave jumps hands separately.
Slow practice is critical for precision in motion.
✦ Interpretation:
Start relentless and desperate, end triumphant.
Bring out the transformation in character.
🎵 Étude No. 5 – Feux Follets (B♭ major)
✦ Analysis:
Light, mysterious, dazzling.
Emphasizes finger independence, staccato skips, and delicate passagework.
✦ Tutorial Tips:
Play hand movements close to keys.
Use fingertip control, avoid arm weight.
✦ Interpretation:
Think of flickering fire or fairy lights.
Never heavy—tone should shimmer.
🎵 Étude No. 6 – Vision (G minor)
✦ Analysis:
Majestic, dark, apocalyptic.
Full chords, grand themes.
✦ Tutorial Tips:
Use arm weight for chordal passages.
Pedal carefully to avoid blurring.
✦ Interpretation:
Play like a massive organ or orchestra.
Noble, tragic tone.
🎵 Étude No. 7 – Eroica (E♭ major)
✦ Analysis:
Heroic march with dotted rhythms and fanfares.
Bold thematic material and left-hand octaves.
✦ Tutorial Tips:
Dotted rhythms must stay tight.
Alternate wrist and finger technique for power and stamina.
✦ Interpretation:
Think of a triumphal entry or procession.
Noble defiance, rhythmic precision.
🎵 Étude No. 8 – Wilde Jagd (C minor)
✦ Analysis:
Depicts a wild hunt.
Rapid octaves, hand crossings, and broken chords.
✦ Tutorial Tips:
Drill fast passages hands separately, aiming for evenness.
Plan pedaling to control resonance.
✦ Interpretation:
Keep ferocity and clarity balanced.
Unrelenting energy, vivid narrative.
🎵 Étude No. 9 – Ricordanza (A♭ major)
✦ Analysis:
Tender and nostalgic.
Highly embellished melodic writing—bel canto style.
✦ Tutorial Tips:
Study ornaments slowly, group notes.
Phrase with rubato and breathing.
✦ Interpretation:
Play like a romantic reminiscence.
Poetic and lyrical; avoid sounding mechanical.
🎵 Étude No. 10 – (Untitled – often “Appassionata”) (F minor)
✦ Analysis:
Fiery, passionate, dramatic.
Large-scale structure with complex development.
✦ Tutorial Tips:
Balance voicing in thick textures.
Careful tempo control in accelerandos and ritardandos.
✦ Interpretation:
Brooding intensity, Chopin-like storminess.
Shape climaxes carefully.
🎵 Étude No. 11 – Harmonies du soir (D♭ major)
✦ Analysis:
Impressionistic, rich harmonic color.
Uses arpeggios, chromaticism, and wide voicing.
✦ Tutorial Tips:
Study pedaling in layers: half-pedals, flutter-pedal, dry pedal.
Voice inner harmonies with sensitivity.
✦ Interpretation:
One of the most poetic and sensuous études.
Think of evening light, blurred colors, mystery.
🎵 Étude No. 12 – Chasse-neige (B♭ minor)
✦ Analysis:
Evokes a snowstorm.
Features tremolos, rapid arpeggios, and chromatic whirlwinds.
✦ Tutorial Tips:
Practice with soft touch, close to keys.
Use pedal to support atmosphere, not smear texture.
✦ Interpretation:
Build gradually into a blizzard-like climax.
Cold, relentless, yet hypnotically beautiful.
🧠 Final Notes
This cycle is a spiritual and pianistic journey—from clarity (No. 1) to transcendence and dissolution (No. 12).
The études require complete command of tone, rhythm, structure, and emotion.
Use them not only to show virtuosity, but to explore color, character, and dramatic storytelling.
History
The Transcendental Études, S.139 by Franz Liszt are more than just a set of piano pieces; they represent a lifetime of pianistic innovation, personal evolution, and Romantic idealism. Their history is a story of ambition, transformation, and transcendence—mirroring Liszt’s own development as a composer, performer, and visionary.
A Journey Across Three Versions
The origins of the Transcendental Études go back to 1826, when the teenage Liszt, still a prodigy under the influence of Czerny and Beethoven, published a set of Études, Op. 6. These early pieces were technically advanced for a boy of 15, yet modest compared to what would come.
Over a decade later, in 1837, Liszt—now a traveling virtuoso and cultural phenomenon—returned to the project with fresh ambition. He expanded the earlier pieces into a new, much more formidable set titled Douze Grandes Études. These were vast, unwieldy, and devilishly difficult—almost unplayable by anyone other than Liszt himself. He had pushed the boundaries of piano technique but at the cost of accessibility.
Then, in 1852, at the height of his maturity and spiritual depth, Liszt revised the études once more. This final version is what we now call the Transcendental Études, S.139. Rather than merely simplifying the 1837 version, Liszt refined and reconceived them. He preserved their technical demands but gave each one poetic identity, musical purpose, and expressive freedom. Some were renamed or given evocative titles, like Mazeppa, Feux Follets, or Chasse-neige—transforming them from pure études into character pieces that invite storytelling, not just dexterity.
Romantic Idealism and the Poetic Vision
Liszt’s aesthetic at the time was steeped in Romantic philosophy, inspired by figures like Victor Hugo, Goethe, and Byron. His friend and companion Marie d’Agoult (writing as Daniel Stern) encouraged his artistic depth, and the literary circle around him valued the blending of music and meaning.
In this context, the Transcendental Études were not merely technical studies, but musical poems. They explore human states: triumph (Eroica), nostalgia (Ricordanza), violence (Wilde Jagd), serenity (Paysage), and dissolution (Chasse-neige). The idea of “transcendence” is not only pianistic—conquering the instrument—but also philosophical: rising above limitations of form, emotion, and self.
The Legacy and Impact
Despite their artistic significance, the Transcendental Études were seldom performed in their entirety during Liszt’s lifetime. They were too demanding and required a new kind of pianist—one who could combine virtuosity with interpretive insight. It was not until the 20th century, through pianists like Vladimir Horowitz, Claudio Arrau, and Maurizio Pollini, that the full cycle gained visibility as a monumental suite.
Liszt dedicated the final set to his pupil Carl Czerny, closing a circle that began in his youth. Yet, he had outgrown Czerny’s model of the étude as mechanical drill. Liszt’s Transcendental Études elevated the genre, influencing generations of composers—Debussy, Rachmaninoff, Scriabin, Ligeti—who sought to merge technique with imagination.
Ultimately, the Transcendental Études are a testament to Liszt’s dual nature: the firebrand virtuoso and the spiritual seeker. In them, we hear both the fury of the performer and the introspection of the philosopher. Their history is not just the story of a set of pieces—it’s the unfolding of Liszt’s entire artistic identity.
Chronology
The chronology of Franz Liszt’s Transcendental Études, S.139 reflects his evolving artistic maturity and the transformation of the étude from a technical exercise into a visionary form of poetic expression. Below is a detailed chronological overview of how this set developed across Liszt’s lifetime.
🎹 1826 – Étude en douze exercices, Op. 6 (S.136)
Age 15, Liszt composed and published his first set of twelve études, titled Étude en douze exercices.
These early works, though technically challenging, follow the classical model of Czerny-style finger studies, with relatively simple musical ideas.
They are in the same keys as the final Transcendental Études and form the structural foundation for later versions.
🔥 1837 – Douze Grandes Études (S.137)
At age 26, Liszt revised the 1826 set into radically expanded, virtuosic concert études, titled Douze Grandes Études.
These études were extraordinarily difficult, demanding wide leaps, hand crossings, and massive chordal textures—essentially tailored for Liszt himself.
The form, drama, and pianistic range became orchestral in conception.
However, they were too complex for most pianists of the time and were rarely played.
✨ 1851–1852 – Études d’exécution transcendante, S.139
Now in his early 40s, Liszt undertook a final revision.
He refined the 1837 études, shortening and clarifying many of them while keeping their essential difficulty and emotional weight.
He gave programmatic titles to most (e.g., Mazeppa, Ricordanza, Chasse-neige), aligning them with Romantic literature and imagery.
Published in 1852 and dedicated to Carl Czerny, his former teacher.
📜 Additional Historical Notes
Liszt had planned a prelude and fugue to accompany the cycle, though only sketches exist.
The 12 études are in a circle of fifths, spanning from C major to B♭ minor.
Liszt never performed the full set publicly in one concert.
The work was rediscovered and widely performed in the 20th century.
Impacts & Influences
The Transcendental Études, S.139 by Franz Liszt have had a profound and lasting impact on the history of piano music, shaping the trajectory of virtuosity, expression, and compositional thought in the Romantic era and beyond. These twelve pieces didn’t just push the boundaries of piano technique—they redefined the étude itself, elevating it into a work of artistic substance and poetic vision. Their influence can be traced across composers, pianists, and aesthetic ideals.
🎹 1. Redefining the Étude: From Drill to Drama
Before Liszt, études were primarily technical exercises (as with Czerny or Clementi), meant to develop hand facility, not to be performed on stage. Liszt’s Transcendental Études were revolutionary because they:
Transformed études into concert repertoire.
Embedded narrative, mood, and imagery into virtuosic textures.
Combined mechanical demands with spiritual and emotional substance.
This reconceptualization paved the way for composers like Chopin, Scriabin, Rachmaninoff, and Debussy to write études as poetic performance works.
🎼 2. Influence on Later Composers
Liszt’s transcendental vision directly or indirectly influenced a lineage of composers who wrote études with artistic and expressive goals:
✅ Romantic and Post-Romantic Composers:
Frédéric Chopin’s Études, while written earlier, were profoundly deepened in spirit by Liszt’s approach.
Alexander Scriabin adopted Liszt’s mystical, virtuosic writing in his own Études, pushing toward transcendental harmonic language.
Sergei Rachmaninoff’s Études-Tableaux blend visual imagery with pianistic poetry—clearly in Liszt’s lineage.
Claude Debussy’s late études are more abstract, but reflect Liszt’s idea of character études.
✅ Modern and Contemporary Composers:
György Ligeti’s Études of the 20th century—rhythmically complex and philosophically abstract—stand as descendants of Liszt’s transcendentalism.
Kaikhosru Sorabji, Leopold Godowsky, and Marc-André Hamelin also embraced Liszt’s concept of ultra-virtuosity married to deep art.
🎹 3. Impact on Piano Performance and Virtuosity
Liszt raised the bar for piano technique, setting new standards for:
Hand independence
Extreme dynamic contrast
Wide leaps and double-note passages
Speed, articulation, and endurance
The Transcendental Études became a rite of passage for virtuosos. In the 20th and 21st centuries, pianists such as:
Claudio Arrau
Lazar Berman
Evgeny Kissin
Marc-André Hamelin
Daniil Trifonov
have performed and recorded the complete set, demonstrating that virtuosity must serve expression, not just athletic display—a Lisztian ideal.
🧠 4. Philosophical and Artistic Influence
The Transcendental Études embody the Romantic philosophy of transcendence:
The individual confronting and overcoming impossible odds (Mazeppa, Wilde Jagd)
The sublime in nature (Paysage, Chasse-neige)
Memory and nostalgia (Ricordanza)
Heroic struggle and apotheosis (Eroica)
This connects them not only to music, but to Romantic poetry and art, making them interdisciplinary works that bridge music with literature and philosophy.
🌍 5. Cultural and Historical Legacy
These études helped define the Romantic pianist-composer archetype.
They shaped the idea of the recital as a dramatic, spiritual journey—a concept Liszt essentially invented.
They have been interpreted in films, literature, and academic discourse as symbols of human aspiration and artistic elevation.
✅ Summary: Lasting Impact of Transcendental Études, S.139
Domain Impact
🎼 Étude Genre Elevated to concert art with narrative and poetic identity
🎹 Technique Redefined the limits of what pianists could physically and expressively achieve
🧠 Aesthetic Introduced Romantic ideals of struggle, transcendence, and musical storytelling
🧬 Influence Inspired generations of composers from Rachmaninoff to Ligeti
🌍 Cultural Legacy Became emblems of Romanticism and symbols of artistic transcendence
Franz Liszt’s Transcendental Études continue to inspire awe, humility, and wonder—both for what they demand from pianists and for what they reveal about the human spirit. Their impact is not only technical but deeply existential, reflecting a vision of music as a path to the sublime.
Popular Piece/Book of Collection at That Time?
At the time of their final publication in 1852, Franz Liszt’s Transcendental Études, S.139, were not popular with the general public or the wider community of pianists—certainly not in the way that we understand musical popularity today. Nor were they commercial bestsellers in terms of sheet music sales. Here’s why:
🎭 Reception and Popularity in the 1850s
1. Too Difficult for Most Pianists
The études were still extraordinarily demanding, even in their “simplified” final form compared to the 1837 version (Douze Grandes Études).
Few pianists outside of Liszt himself could even attempt to play them, let alone perform them convincingly.
As a result, they were seen more as curiosities or technical monsters than approachable concert works.
2. Limited Audience for Avant-Garde Music
In 1852, the public taste leaned toward more melodic and lyrical works—think Chopin nocturnes or salon music by Mendelssohn and Schumann.
Liszt’s Transcendental Études were seen as too eccentric, bombastic, or modern.
Music publishers often found such pieces risky to print, since they catered to a very small group of elite pianists.
3. Liszt’s Changing Career
By the early 1850s, Liszt was retreating from his touring career and turning more toward composition, conducting, and religious/spiritual life.
His earlier celebrity as a piano virtuoso didn’t automatically translate into sales of technically intimidating works, especially as his own public performances became rarer.
📜 Sheet Music Sales
The sheet music for S.139 was published by Breitkopf & Härtel in 1852.
It did not sell in large numbers initially, because:
It was too advanced for amateur pianists.
There was little professional demand to perform all 12 in public.
In contrast, more accessible works (like Liszt’s Liebesträume, Consolations, or Hungarian Rhapsodies) sold much better.
🌟 Later Rise to Prominence
It wasn’t until the 20th century that the Transcendental Études began to receive widespread admiration and regular performance:
Claudio Arrau and Lazar Berman began performing and recording the full set.
Pianists like Cziffra, Kissin, and Hamelin helped bring these works into the core virtuosic piano repertoire.
Audiences, critics, and performers grew to appreciate the poetic and philosophical depth, beyond just the technical fireworks.
✅ Summary
Aspect 1850s Reality
Public Popularity Low – not embraced by general audiences
Sheet Music Sales Modest – too difficult for most buyers
Performer Interest Niche – only a few elite virtuosos attempted them
Critical Praise Mixed – admired but often seen as extreme or excessive
Long-Term Legacy Enormous – now considered one of the greatest sets of piano études in history
So no, the Transcendental Études, S.139 were not popular or commercially successful when first published. They were ahead of their time, and it took generations for their true artistic and pianistic value to be fully recognized and appreciated.
Episodes & Trivia
Here are some fascinating episodes and trivia about Franz Liszt’s Transcendental Études, S.139, ranging from their evolution, inspirations, and connections to broader musical and literary culture:
🎬 1. A Project 25 Years in the Making
Liszt began sketching these pieces as a teenager—the earliest versions date from 1826, when he was only 15 years old. He revised them into the ferociously difficult “Douze Grandes Études” (1837), and finally reworked them into the Transcendental Études, S.139 in 1852.
👉 That means he revised the same set three times over 26 years—an unusual commitment even for Liszt.
🎨 2. Poetic Titles by a Poet-Composer
Only in the 1852 version did most of the études receive descriptive titles like Mazeppa, Feux follets, Ricordanza, etc. These were likely added to suggest narrative or emotional imagery, and they reflect Liszt’s deep interest in literature, especially Romantic poetry.
💡 Many believe the titles were inspired by:
Byron (Mazeppa)
Victor Hugo
Goethe and Heine
🐎 3. Mazeppa: Inspired by a Wild Ride
Étude No. 4, Mazeppa, is based on the legendary tale (retold by Byron and Hugo) of a man tied naked to a wild horse and dragged across the steppes as punishment.
🎼 Liszt literally mimics the galloping horse with wild octaves, relentless rhythms, and heroic sweeps. The end of the étude includes the quote:
“Il tombe, mais il se relève… il devient roi.”
He falls, but he rises again… he becomes king.
This reflects the Romantic hero’s journey from struggle to triumph, a core theme of the set.
🔥 4. Feux follets—A Technical Nightmare
Étude No. 5, Feux follets (Will-o’-the-Wisps), is one of the most technically difficult pieces in the entire piano repertoire—not for speed alone, but for its:
Hand-crossings
Unpredictable leaps
Delicate touch and voicing
🎹 Even Liszt’s students found it nearly unplayable at the time.
📜 5. Liszt Removed One Étude from the Set
The original 1837 version had 12 études, each with a key related to the circle of fifths. When Liszt finalized the 1852 version, he removed No. 10 in F major, which left a gap in the key sequence.
Some believe this was for musical or technical reasons, or because the set already had enough weight.
💥 6. The Missing Étude No. 1?
Étude No. 1 (Preludio) is very short and almost improvisational—less than a minute long in many performances. Some believe it serves as a call to arms or a curtain-raiser for the entire cycle, not a “full” étude like the others.
🎵 Its explosive opening is reminiscent of an orchestral fanfare, and it foreshadows thematic material used in later études.
👻 7. “Chasse-neige” as a Metaphor for Oblivion
The final étude, Chasse-neige (Snow-whirl), is haunting and poetic rather than showy. It evokes an avalanche or blizzard, with tremolos and swirling figurations that fade into silence.
Many interpret it as a symbol of death, winter, or the dissolution of the ego—the Romantic sublime taken to a metaphysical level.
📖 8. Franz Liszt as an Étude Pioneer
Liszt wrote more études than any major composer of his era, and the Transcendental Études are part of a broader philosophy for him: that music should be a means of moral, spiritual, and technical elevation—hence “transcendental.”
This ideal later influenced Scriabin, Messiaen, and even Ligeti.
📚 9. They Were Nearly Lost in Time
Despite their ambition, these études were not widely performed or studied until the 20th century. For decades, they were mostly played in parts (Mazeppa, Feux follets) but rarely as a complete set.
Thanks to pianists like Claudio Arrau, Lazar Berman, and Marc-André Hamelin, they were revived and celebrated as masterpieces.
🤯 10. No. 12 Has No Title—but Many Meanings
The final étude, No. 12 in B♭ minor, is simply titled “Chasse-neige”. But in Liszt’s 1837 version, it was titled “L’oubli” (Oblivion).
🧠 Some scholars interpret this as:
The end of memory
A return to silence
A metaphor for the erasure of ego or the passing of time
It serves as a mysterious, poetic close to a cycle that begins with fire (Preludio) and ends in snow (Chasse-neige).
🎹 BONUS TRIVIA: Played Backwards?
Some modern pianists and scholars have proposed performing the études in reverse order, starting with Chasse-neige and ending with Preludio, to emphasize a journey from death to rebirth—a kind of Romantic resurrection.
Similar Compositions / Suits / Collections
If you’re drawn to the epic scale, poetic drama, and technical brilliance of Liszt’s Transcendental Études, S.139, there are several other collections and works—both earlier and later—that share similar goals of virtuosity, expression, and transcendence. Here’s a selection of similar or related compositions, organized by their spiritual, technical, or historical connection to Liszt’s études:
🎹 Similar Étude Collections
🔥 1. Chopin – Études, Op. 10 and Op. 25
Written earlier (1830s), these études established the modern piano étude as a work of both technical and poetic depth.
Chopin’s études focus more on subtle textures than sheer power, but they laid the groundwork that Liszt expanded into the symphonic and transcendental.
🎯 Try: Op. 10 No. 4 (ferocity), Op. 25 No. 6 (dexterity), Op. 25 No. 12 (oceanic power).
🌀 2. Scriabin – Études, Opp. 8, 42, 65
Scriabin’s études evolve from Chopin but move into mysticism and coloristic harmony, like Liszt’s more spiritual later works.
They are often emotionally intense and technically daring, especially in Op. 42 and 65.
🎯 Op. 42 No. 5 is sometimes compared to Liszt’s Feux follets.
🚀 3. Rachmaninoff – Études-Tableaux, Op. 33 and Op. 39
These are tone poems for the piano, blending narrative imagery and Russian grandeur with massive technical demands.
Like Liszt, Rachmaninoff creates études that are both picturesque and pianistically overwhelming.
🎯 Op. 39 No. 1, No. 5, and No. 9 are especially brutal and expressive.
💎 4. Ligeti – Études, Books I–III (1985–2001)
Inspired in part by Liszt’s Feux follets, Ligeti’s études are ultra-modern, but share Liszt’s obsession with texture, rhythm, and transcendence.
They’re often called the “Transcendental Études of the 20th century”.
🎯 Try: Book I No. 3 “Touches bloquées” or Book II No. 10 “Der Zauberlehrling.”
💥 5. Godowsky – 53 Studies on Chopin Études
Perhaps the most insanely difficult études ever written.
They take Chopin’s works and superimpose extra layers of complexity, sometimes for the left hand alone.
Highly “transcendental” in ambition and technique, like Liszt’s S.139.
🎯 Try: Study No. 22 (on Chopin Op. 10 No. 6 for left hand alone).
🎼 Other Lisztian Virtuoso Cycles
🎻 6. Franz Liszt – Grandes Études de Paganini, S.141
Inspired by Paganini’s violin works, these études are as dazzling as S.139, but more focused on technique than narrative.
The famous La Campanella (No. 3) comes from this set.
👑 7. Liszt – Années de pèlerinage, S.160–163
These travel-inspired suites contain some of Liszt’s most poetic, spiritual, and virtuosic writing.
Less étude-like, but deeply connected to the philosophy and lyricism of S.139.
🎯 Try: “Après une lecture de Dante” (Italy II), or “Vallée d’Obermann” (Switzerland I).
🦉 8. Alkan – Études in the Minor Keys, Op. 39
Charles-Valentin Alkan, a friend of Liszt, wrote études that are massive in scale and difficulty.
Includes an entire Concerto for Solo Piano and Symphony for Solo Piano within the set.
🎯 Comparable in ambition and scope to Liszt’s transcendental cycle.
⚔️ 9. Kaikhosru Sorabji – 100 Études transcendantes (1940–44)
One of the most enormous piano projects ever undertaken, these études are hugely influenced by Liszt in name and vision, though in a dense, idiosyncratic style.
Rarely played due to extreme length and difficulty.
🧩 Bonus: Thematic or Aesthetic Cousins
🏞️ 10. Debussy – Études (1915)
While stylistically distant, Debussy’s études are conceptually similar: each étude explores a single pianistic idea, but with coloristic and poetic depth.
⚡ 11. Sorabji, Busoni, and Szymanowski
These later Romantic and post-Romantic composers continue Liszt’s tradition of pushing piano music to extremes—spiritually, emotionally, and technically.
Summary Table
Work Composer Similarity
Études Op. 10 & 25 Chopin Foundational poetic études
Études-Tableaux Rachmaninoff Tone-painting with virtuosity
Paganini Études Liszt Violin-inspired pianism
Op. 39 Études Alkan Gigantic form, difficulty
Études Books I–III Ligeti Modern transcendence
Godowsky’s Chopin Studies Godowsky Hyper-virtuosic variations
Années de pèlerinage Liszt Philosophical travel music
Op. 8 & 42 Études Scriabin Mystical and brilliant
100 Études transcendantes Sorabji Monumental and arcane
(This article was generated by ChatGPT. And it’s just a reference document for discovering music you don’t know yet.)
Best Classical Recordings
on YouTube
Best Classical Recordings
on Spotify