Posted on by Jean-Michel Serres

Notes on Impromptu, CG 580 by Charles Gounod, Information, Analysis and Performance Tutorial

General Overview

Charles Gounod’s Impromptu, CG 580 is a solo piano piece, composed in 1888 and published the same year in Paris by Lemoine & Fils. It is a relatively short work, typical of the impromptu genre, which suggests a spontaneous and free composition, though often structured.

Here’s a general overview:

Genre and Instrumentation: It’s an impromptu, a popular genre during the Romantic era, and is written for solo piano.

Year of Composition and Publication: The work was composed in 1888.

Stylistic Context: Gounod (1818–1893) is a central figure in French music of the third quarter of the 19th century, known primarily for his operas (such as “Faust” and “Roméo et Juliette”) and sacred music (“Ave Maria”). Although less known than his vocal works, his piano pieces also reflect his Romantic style, characterized by lyrical melody, refined harmony, and a sense of French taste.

Dedication: The piece is dedicated “À Ses Amis Jules Simon” (To His Friends Jules Simon).

Musical Characteristics: Without a detailed analysis of the score, one can expect to find Gounod’s distinctive qualities in this impromptu:

  • Melody: Clear, singing, and often expressive melodic lines.
  • Harmony: Rich and nuanced harmonic writing, with interesting modulations.
  • Form: Although improvisatory in spirit, an impromptu generally retains a recognizable structure, often tripartite (ABA) or based on a recurring motif.

In essence, the Impromptu, CG 580 offers a glimpse into Gounod’s talent for instrumental music, demonstrating his expertise in piano writing and his adherence to the Romantic ideals of the time. It is a piece that, like many of his piano works, deserves to be discovered beyond his most famous compositions.

Musical Characteristics

Charles Gounod’s Impromptu, CG 580, composed in 1888 for solo piano, exhibits musical characteristics typical of the French Romantic style of the second half of the 19th century, of which Gounod was a major representative. Here are the key elements of its composition:

  1. Form and Structure:

    • Impromptu: As its name suggests, this piece belongs to the impromptu genre, which is characterized by apparent spontaneity and a certain formal freedom. However, even Romantic impromptus tend to follow a recognizable structure, often a tripartite form (ABA’ or ABA) or a rondo form, allowing for the development of melodic ideas.
    • Short Duration: Impromptus are generally concise pieces, focused on expressing a single mood or musical idea.

  2. Melody:

    • Lyricism: Melody is one of Gounod’s strengths. One can expect singing, fluid, and expressive melodic lines, characteristic of instrumental bel canto. These melodies are often memorable and lyrical.
    • Clarity and Elegance: Gounod’s melodic style is often imbued with clarity and elegance, avoiding excessive complexity in favor of direct expression.

  3. Harmony:

    • Refined Romantic Harmony: Gounod’s harmony is typical of the Romantic era, using extended chords (ninths, elevenths), subtle modulations, and chromatics to add color and emotion.
    • Sense of Tonality: Although he uses modulations, Gounod maintains a clear sense of the main tonality (the piece is in G Major), with satisfying returns to tonal centers.
    • Pedal Use: As with many Romantic piano works, the use of the sustain pedal is crucial for creating specific resonance and “sound,” amplifying the harmony and lyricism.

  4. Rhythm and Texture:

    • Rhythmic Variety: One can anticipate a variety of rhythmic figurations to support the melody and create interesting movement, ranging from slower, contemplative passages to more animated sections.
    • Piano Texture: Gounod was a competent piano composer. The piece utilizes the instrument’s range, with arpeggios, chords, and virtuosic passages that showcase the pianist’s abilities. The texture can vary between homophonic passages (accompanied melody) and more contrapuntal sections, though the focus generally remains on the melody.

  5. Expressivity and Character:

    • Poetry and Sentiment: The Impromptu, like most Romantic pieces, aims to express a particular emotion or atmosphere. Gounod is known for his ability to evoke feelings of tenderness, reverie, or melancholy.
    • Implicit Rubato: While not always explicitly indicated, the interpretation of Gounod’s Impromptu would benefit from a certain rhythmic flexibility (rubato) to highlight melodic and harmonic nuances, a characteristic of the Romantic style.

In summary, Gounod’s Impromptu, CG 580 is a piano piece that illustrates his ability to combine expressive melody, rich harmony, and idiomatic writing for the piano, all within a concise and elegant form, typical of his approach to French instrumental music of the period.

Analysis, Tutorial, Interpretation, and Important Playing Points

Providing a complete analysis, a detailed tutorial, varied interpretations, and all important playing points for a piece like Gounod’s Impromptu, CG 580 without having the score in front of me is a challenge. However, I can offer you a general guide and applicable advice for this piece, based on Gounod’s musical characteristics and the impromptu genre.

General Analysis (Based on Impressionism and Gounod’s Style):

  • Form: Most likely a ternary form (ABA’ or ABA), common in impromptus.
    • Section A: Introduces the main theme, often lyrical and expressive. Establishes the overall mood.
    • Section B: Contrasts with Section A, perhaps through a change of key (related key), tempo, rhythm, or character. It might be more agitated, more contemplative, or simply a variation of the thematic material.
    • Section A’ or A: Return of the main theme, often with variations or embellishment. The coda (ending) solidifies the overall impression and provides a conclusion.
  • Key: The piece is in G Major, a bright and pastoral key, conducive to expressing serene or joyful feelings.
  • Melodic Themes: Expect singing, clear, and elegant melodies, typical of Gounod. They may be built on simple motifs but gracefully developed.
  • Harmony: Refined Romantic harmony, with enriched chords (sevenths, ninths), fluid modulations to neighboring keys, and the use of chromaticism for color.
  • Texture: The piano texture will likely be dominated by an accompanied melody (melodic right hand, chordal or arpeggiated left hand). There may be chordal passages, more complex arpeggios, or figurations for the left hand.

Tutorial for Learning (General Approach):

  1. Get the Score: This is the first and most important step! Without the score, any instruction is purely speculative. Gounod’s scores are generally available in the public domain or through music publishers.
  2. Sight-Reading and First Approach:
    • Play the piece slowly, without aiming for perfection, to get a general idea of the melody, harmony, and structure.
    • Identify sections A and B.
  3. Hands Separate Practice:
    • Right Hand: Focus on note accuracy, melodic line fluidity, phrasing, and expression. Sing the melody to internalize its contour.
    • Left Hand: Work on rhythmic regularity, precision of chords or arpeggios, and sound balance so that it supports the melody without overpowering it. Pay attention to the bass notes.
  4. Hands Together Practice:
    • Start very slowly. Ensure both hands are synchronized.
    • Work in small sections (measures, musical phrases).
    • Gradually increase the tempo.
  5. Potential Technical Difficulties:
    • Legato and Phrasing: Gounod is lyrical, so legatos are crucial.
    • Sound Balance: Keeping the melody prominent while having an expressive but discreet left hand.
    • Pedal Management: Essential for legato and resonance.
    • Minor Virtuosic Passages: If any, work on them separately and methodically.

Possible Interpretations:

  • Lyricism and Song: Gounod is first and foremost a melodist. Interpret the melody as if you were singing it. Think of the “breath” of the phrase.
  • Elegance and Restraint: Avoid excessive sentimentality. Gounod, even when romantic, maintains a certain French restraint and elegance.
  • Nuances and Dynamics: Use a wide dynamic palette, from expressive pianissimo to passionate forte, but always with good taste. Crescendos and decrescendos should be gradual and well-controlled.
  • Rubato: Subtle rubato is essential. It’s not about playing at your own pace, but about “stealing” a little time from a note or phrase to make it more expressive, and “returning” it later. It should always serve the musical phrase and feel natural.
  • Atmosphere: The piece can evoke reverie, serenity, tenderness, or gentle joy. Let the work speak through you.

Important Points for Piano Playing:

  • Sonority: Aim for a round, warm sound. Work on the quality of note attack.
  • Pedal: The sustain pedal is your friend, but don’t overuse it. Change it with each harmonic shift or to clarify the texture. It should serve to connect notes and provide resonance, not to muddy the sound.
  • Phrasing: Clearly identify the beginning and end of each musical phrase. Give direction to each phrase.
  • Tempo: Choose a tempo that allows you to play the piece with ease, clarity, and expression. Don’t sacrifice musicality for speed. Gounod’s tempo indication is a good basis, but interpretation may vary slightly.
  • Articulation: Respect the articulation markings (legato, staccato, tenuto, etc.) that contribute to the piece’s character.
  • Active Listening: Constantly listen to what you are playing. Are you producing the sound you want? Is the balance good? Is the melody clear?
  • Knowledge of the Composer and Period: Understanding Gounod’s style and the context of French Romanticism will enrich your interpretation. Listen to other works by Gounod (operas, mélodies, other piano pieces) to immerse yourself in his world.

For a truly specific analysis and tutorial, having the score would be necessary, but these general tips should help you approach Charles Gounod’s Impromptu, CG 580 with musicality and intent.

History

The history of Charles Gounod’s Impromptu, CG 580 is that of a small musical gem, a late reflection of his genius, born in the final years of his prolific life. In 1888, when Gounod composed this piano piece, he was already a revered figure in French music. His name resonated in opera houses worldwide thanks to immortal operas like “Faust” and “Roméo et Juliette,” and his “Ave Maria” was a universal hymn.

Yet, despite his stature as the “pope” of French music, Gounod continued to write, exploring various genres, including chamber music and piano pieces. The Impromptu CG 580 falls into this more intimate vein of his work. The impromptu genre itself, popular during the Romantic era, suggests a sudden inspiration, a musical idea spontaneously bursting forth, like a fleeting yet charming thought put to paper.

This piece is dedicated “À Ses Amis Jules Simon” (To His Friends Jules Simon). Jules Simon was an important political and intellectual figure of the time, a philosopher, writer, and statesman who notably served as Prime Minister of France. This dedication highlights the bonds of friendship and mutual respect that existed between the artist and the intellectual, illustrating how musicians of this period often moved within influential social and cultural circles. It was not a commission for a grand public occasion, but rather a gift, a token of affection or esteem, offered to a close friend.

Composed and published in 1888 in Paris by Lemoine & Fils, this Impromptu likely did not aim for the symphonic or operatic grandeur that had made Gounod famous. Instead, it was a salon piece, intended to be played in the intimacy of bourgeois homes or at private musical evenings. At a time when the piano was central to domestic musical life, such pieces allowed amateurs to experience the style of great masters, and professional pianists to include short character pieces in their recitals.

Thus, the Impromptu, CG 580, though modest in size and scope compared to Gounod’s operatic monuments, is a valuable testament to the composer’s creative perseverance and his ability to infuse lyricism and elegance even into the most concise forms. It is a piece that, through its dedication and style, takes us back to the atmosphere of late 19th-century Parisian salons, where art and friendship harmoniously intertwined.

Episodes and Anecdotes

Charles Gounod’s piano pieces, particularly his impromptus, are works that, while lacking the grandiose resonance of his operas, are imbued with his characteristic grace and melody. As for the Impromptu, CG 580, specific anecdotes about it are rare, precisely because it is a salon piece, without the same public exposure as an opera or a mass.

However, we can imagine some contextual “episodes” and “anecdotes” that shed light on Gounod’s life and the genre of this work:

  1. The Art of the “Musical Gift”:
    The Impromptu, CG 580, is dedicated “À Ses Amis Jules Simon.” Jules Simon was a prominent figure in French political and intellectual life of the late 19th century. He was a philosopher, writer, and, at one point, Prime Minister. The anecdote here lies not so much in the piece itself, but in the tradition of the era. Composers often offered piano pieces as “musical gifts” to their friends or patrons. One can imagine Gounod, already 70 years old in 1888, sitting at his piano, perhaps after an inspiring conversation with Simon, and sketching this elegant melody while thinking of his friend. It wasn’t a paid commission, but a gesture of affection, a way to honor a lasting relationship. This piece was undoubtedly played in Simon’s salon, bearing witness to the friendship between two giants of their respective fields.

  2. The “Master of Melody” at Work:
    Gounod was universally recognized as a “master of melody.” His talent for creating lyrical and memorable tunes was his hallmark. It is said that Gounod, even for small pieces like this impromptu, had an almost natural approach to melody. His students and contemporaries claimed that he only had to “sing” the melody for it to be born, with no apparent effort. The anecdote here would be that, even without grand operatic drama, Gounod infused his melodic gift into this piece, transforming it into a little wordless romance, where the piano sings with the same sweetness as the voices in his operas.

  3. The Last Years of Creation:
    In 1888, Gounod was nearing the end of his life (he would die in 1893). Although he experienced periods of personal doubt and difficulty, particularly with Georgina Weldon in England, he continued to compose with impressive regularity. The Impromptu, CG 580, is one of these late works that show a form of serenity and maturity. The anecdote would be that of a composer who, after a life filled with successes and challenges, still found joy and inspiration in simple, pure forms. One could imagine Gounod, in his study, sketching this piece, not with the ambition of a new “Faust,” but with the quiet pleasure of art for art’s sake, a moment of pure musicality offered to a friend.

  4. The Discreet Influence:
    Unlike his operas, which influenced an entire generation, Gounod’s piano pieces had a more discreet influence. However, they helped establish a certain “French taste” for melody and elegance in piano playing, perhaps paving the way for composers like Fauré or Debussy, even if the latter later explored very different harmonic paths. The anecdote would be to see how, through works like this Impromptu, Gounod kept alive a tradition of lyricism and refinement that is an essential part of French musical identity.

In short, while the Impromptu, CG 580, may not have generated grand public stories, its existence is an anecdote in itself: that of a great master who, until his last years, continued to compose charming and melodious music, not for glory, but for friendship and the intrinsic beauty of art.

Style(s), Movement(s), and Period of Composition

Charles Gounod’s Impromptu, CG 580, composed in 1888, clearly falls within the French Romantic style of the second half of the 19th century. To answer your questions about its “old or new,” “traditional or innovative” character, and its precise stylistic positioning:

  1. Old or New at that Time?

    In 1888, Gounod’s Impromptu was relatively traditional rather than radically new. Gounod was a well-established composer whose style had formed and matured several decades earlier. He represented the “old guard” of French music, a pillar of opera and lyrical vocal music.

    At the same time, more “new” and avant-garde movements were beginning to emerge or gain momentum. For example, Symbolism in poetry and Impressionism in painting were already well present, and their musical equivalents (with composers like Debussy, who was beginning to develop his own language) were starting to appear. Verismo in Italy was also a novelty. Gounod, however, remained faithful to a proven Romantic aesthetic.

  2. Traditional or Innovative?

    The Impromptu is decidedly traditional. It does not seek to break the harmonic, formal, or melodic codes of the time. On the contrary, it exploits the conventions of the impromptu genre and the Romantic style in a refined and elegant manner.

    Innovative elements would be found more in the likes of Richard Wagner (who had shaken musical Europe) or the beginnings of musical Impressionism, which would redefine harmony and form. Gounod, with this piece, reinforces rather than revolutionizes.

  3. Polyphony or Monophony?

    The dominant texture is accompanied monody, meaning a clear, singing melody (often in the right hand) supported by a harmonic-rhythmic accompaniment (primarily in the left hand). It is therefore neither pure monophony (a single melodic line without accompaniment) nor complex polyphony in the manner of a Bach fugue, although contrapuntal elements may appear occasionally to enrich the texture. The emphasis is on the main melodic line.

  4. Classical, Romantic, Nationalist, Impressionist, Neoclassical, Post-Romantic, or Modernist?

    Romantic: This is the primary category. The Impromptu exhibits all the characteristics of Romanticism:

    • Lyricism and melodic expressiveness: Melody is the central element, expressive and singing.
    • Rich and colorful harmony: Use of seventh, ninth chords, chromatic modulations to create emotional atmospheres.
    • Free form (the impromptu): Although structured, it gives an impression of spontaneity.
    • Emphasis on feeling and atmosphere.
    • Idiomatic use of the piano: Exploitation of the instrument’s sonorities and capabilities.

    Not Classical: Although there is formal clarity, it lacks the structural rigor and emotional restraint of Classicism (Mozart, Haydn).

    Not Nationalist (in the strict sense): Gounod is a French composer, and his style is imbued with French elegance and good taste. However, he does not belong to a conscious nationalist movement that would seek to incorporate folkloric elements or specific national narratives, as Dvořák, Sibelius, or Tchaikovsky would. His music is more universal in its Romantic expression.

    Not Impressionist: Impressionism, which would fully emerge with Debussy and Ravel, is characterized by more floating harmonies, ethereal textures, the absence of clear melodic lines in favor of timbres and colors, and a dilution of traditional tonality. Gounod’s Impromptu is very tonal and melodic.

    Not Neoclassical: Neoclassicism is an early 20th-century movement that reacted against the excesses of Romanticism by returning to the clarity and forms of the Baroque and Classical periods (Stravinsky, Prokofiev). This is not the case here.

    Not Post-Romantic (in the German sense): Post-Romanticism (Mahler, Strauss) pushed Romantic gigantism, orchestration, and expressiveness to extremes. Gounod is Romantic, but not in this “excessive” vein. One could say he is “post-Romantic” in the sense that he composed at the end of the Romantic period, but his style does not show the characteristics of a break or hyper-extension of this movement.

    Not Modernist: Modernism implies a radical break with the past, the exploration of atonality, dodecaphony, or other totally new harmonic and formal languages (Schoenberg, Stravinsky after his Neoclassicism). Gounod remains firmly rooted in tradition.

In summary:

Charles Gounod’s Impromptu, CG 580 is a typically French Romantic work, traditional for its time (1888), characterized by accompanied monody and elegant lyricism. It reflects the mature style of a composer who, though elderly, remained faithful to the aesthetic canons that had brought him fame, far from the avant-garde experiments that were then beginning to manifest in other musical currents.

Similar Compositions

Charles Gounod’s Impromptu, CG 580 is a character piece for solo piano, typical of the French Romantic style of the late 19th century. If you appreciate this work for its lyricism, singing melody, and elegance, here are some composers and types of compositions you might explore:

I. From Charles Gounod Himself:

Gounod wrote other solo piano pieces that share the same aesthetic:

  • Other Impromptus or Nocturnes: He composed other short character pieces, often with evocative titles like “Rêverie,” “Souvenance” (Nocturne), “La Veneziana” (Barcarolle). They are often lyrical and explore varied atmospheres.
  • Pieces Extracted from Operas: Some piano transcriptions of his most famous opera arias can have a similar quality, though they are not original compositions for piano.

II. French Composers of the Same Period (or Slightly Earlier/Later) with a Similar Piano Style:

These composers often shared Gounod’s melodic elegance and refined harmony:

  • Camille Saint-Saëns (1835–1921): Although more eclectic and sometimes more virtuosic, Saint-Saëns wrote many charming salon pieces, impromptus, preludes, etudes, and romances for piano that share a sense of classicism and melody.
    • Examples: His Etudes Op. 52, the Bagatelles, or some of his Romances sans paroles.
  • Gabriel Fauré (1845–1924): His lyricism is perhaps more intimate and his harmonies more subtle, but elegance and melodic beauty are very present.
    • Examples: His Nocturnes, Barcarolles, and Impromptus. Nocturne No. 1, Op. 33 No. 1 or Impromptu No. 1, Op. 25 would be good starting points.
  • Georges Bizet (1838–1875): Less prolific for solo piano than Gounod or Fauré, but his few pieces are charming.
    • Examples: His Chants du Rhin, or the Chromatic Concert Variations.
  • Cécile Chaminade (1857–1944): A very popular composer in her time for her salon pieces, often brilliant and melodic.
    • Examples: Her Concert Etudes, Scarf Dance, or Theme Varié Op. 89.
  • Reynaldo Hahn (1874–1947): Later, but his style is deeply rooted in the melodic tradition and elegance of Parisian salons.
    • Examples: His Portraits de peintres, or pieces like “Le Rossignol éperdu.”

III. Other Romantic Composers Who Excelled in Piano Character Pieces:

The genre of the impromptu, nocturne, song without words, etc., was highly prized throughout Romantic Europe.

  • Franz Schubert (1797–1828): He is the undisputed master of the impromptu. His Impromptus D. 899 (Op. 90) and D. 935 (Op. 142) are absolute classics, full of melancholy and lyricism, though often of a darker emotional depth than Gounod.
  • Frédéric Chopin (1810–1849): The “poet of the piano.” His Nocturnes, Preludes, and his four Impromptus are perfect examples of Romantic character pieces, with immense harmonic and melodic richness. Impromptu No. 1 in A-flat Major, Op. 29 could be a good parallel.
  • Robert Schumann (1810–1856): His cycles of character pieces are famous for their emotional depth and imagination.
    • Examples: Kinderszenen (Scenes from Childhood) Op. 15 (especially “Träumerei”), Fantasiestücke (Fantasy Pieces) Op. 12.
  • Felix Mendelssohn (1809–1847): His Songs Without Words are small masterpieces of lyricism and elegance. They are among the most directly comparable character pieces in terms of accessibility and melodic charm.
  • Stephen Heller (1813–1888): A composer of very popular salon pieces in his time, often elegant and well-written for the piano.
    • Examples: His Etudes Op. 45, Nocturnes, or Preludes.

By exploring these composers and genres, you will rediscover the lyrical spirit, harmonic elegance, and melodic beauty that characterize Charles Gounod’s Impromptu, CG 580.

Is there a specific aspect of Gounod’s work or other Romantic piano pieces you’d like to delve into further?

(This article was generated by Gemini. And it’s just a reference document for discovering music you don’t know yet.)

Best Classical Recordings
on YouTube

Best Classical Recordings
on Spotify

Jean-Michel Serres Apfel Café Music QR Codes Center English 2024.